It has been nearly two years since Rod Dreher infected American religious discourse with The Benedict Option, an under-theorized mishmash of derivative ideas and conclusions meant to finance its author’s extravagant trips to foreign dinner tables. By spawning a litany of lesser-known “Options” in magazine articles and web-logs, Dreher managed to unwittingly play into liberalism’s hands. Liberalism is not concerned with the “right life” or the “best life” per se, but rather with the “right” or “best life” the individual defines for himself. And so the “Benedict Option” (whatever it means) becomes a choice among many, a mere possibility whose goodness is measured by the number of adherents rather than the substance of its claims. Luckily none of the other proposed “Options” ever gained much traction, perhaps because there is nothing more intellectually loathsome than to be a derivative idea of a derivative idea that, in and of itself, is not particularly impressive.
One other related consequence of Dreher’s drivel is the reduction of all things political to “Options” in the minds of contemporary American Christians, particularly Catholics. Take, for instance, the integralist revival inspired in no small part by The Josias and the earlier writings of its contributors. Both friends and foes of integralism have a tendency to treat it as an “Option,” a political posture that is worth adopting — at least in word — on a visceral basis alone. Integralism “sounds cool” to a certain type of 20/30-something Catholic disillusioned with American politics and its two main parties. Integralism seems “edgy,” and the willingness of integralists to callback to supposed “golden ages” in the distant past or more questionable eras of religious-political union in the last century has a polarizing effect that too many of these otherwise well-meaning Catholics revel in. This is contrary to one of if not the most central tenant of integralism, namely that integralists are doing nothing more or less than holding to the Catholic Church’s indefectible teachings. Integralists do not advance new doctrines or novel theological speculation; they merely adhere to the proper ordering of the spiritual and temporal powers.
On its face, that’s incredibly less “sexy” (or shocking) than saying that one longs for the days of the Inquisition or proudly hangs portrait’s of Franco and Salazar in their “study” (ok, fine, parents’ basement). By promoting a caricature of integralism, one that is more fit to be a Right Wing Death Squad t-shirt design than a topic of serious discussion, these unwitting integralists feed integralist’s critics with ample ammunition to gun-down the integralist thesis (or, rather, a certain degraded idea of the integralist thesis). That is unhelpful. For until the time comes that integralism, properly understood, is taken as neither a novelty nor a romantic hope, it will not only fail to gain traction in the wider Catholic Church, but few if any will begin the heavy lifting required to operationalize integralism in a socio-political environment beset by liberalism. To put it another way, for as long as integralism remains mired in useless discussions centered on some of its adherents’ silly social-media excesses and poor rhetorical choices, it will always have the appearance of an idea, of an “Option,” that can be freely chosen (or not) without serious intellectual and moral consequences. If that is all integralism truly is, then we need it not at all.
None of this is to say that integralism is beyond criticism or that integralists cannot disagree among themselves. One challenge to integralism that remains more hypothetical than realized at this stage is the Eastern Orthodox concept of symphonia. Leaving to the side for the moment any criticism of “symphonia in practice” as opposed to “symphonia as proposed,” symphonia does away with the hierarchical structure of the spiritual and temporal powers intrinsic to integralism in favor of an integrated model of ecclesiastical and secular authority. Under symphonia, temporal power is not directly subordinate to the spiritual, but rather interwoven with it. In the Byzantine, and later Russian Tsarist, iterations of symphonia, the emperor is vested with a coordinate role in protecting and promoting the true religion alongside the Church hierarchy (specifically the patriarch). Some argue that this is necessary insofar as the Christian East knows nothing of a central ecclesiastical authority figure in the way Western Christendom does with the papacy. While the bishops may, in theory, all be equal successors to the Apostles, it is the temporal ruler, the emperor, who binds them together and calls them forth with the dogmatic unity of the Church is threatened. Integralism, by symphonia’s lights, goes too far in subordinating the temporal power to the spiritual while also claiming indirect temporal authority to the spiritual power. This hierarchical structure makes the temporal the handmaid of the spiritual, an arrangement that is both theologically unsound and practical untenable.
Integralist adherents, mainly Latin Catholics, may wish to dismiss symphonia’s claims on the thin ground that it belongs to the Christian East, specifically the Eastern Orthodox, and therefore has no say in the doctrinal structure of the Catholic Church. Maybe. However, does not the Christian East no less than the Christian West belong by right to the Catholic Church, that is, the one Universal Church of Christ? Is it so clear at this stage that integralism has vanquished symphonia? Or do both models have room to exist within One Church? There is no space to answer those or a myriad of other questions here. Rather, they are brought up only to suggest that even if integralism should be conceptualized not as an “Option” but rather part and parcel of the Church’s historic social doctrine, then can it stand alone when an equally ancient and arguably more successful model (at least for a time) in symphonia is also available? For those inclined to dismiss symphonia out of hand, remember that without it there would be no Nicene Creed.
March 17, 2019
I’m guessing it wouldn’t map on precisely, but would Symphonia have anything in common with the general Ghibelline claim of strong imperial authority in matters of the Church? I’d imagine many knee-jerk complaints about the Ghibelline model could be addressed by the proposed vs. actual distinction. We have the example of Sigismund at Constance as a kind of image of how it works properly. Frederick II as a kind of tragic hero of the model. Charles I/V attempted to practice it it. Dante’s De Monarchia seems to fall into this camp as a theoretical proponent. Kanorowicz’s “Two Bodies” show the thought was present throughout the middle ages. Perhaps Symphonia is present, in a form, in the west? Which both makes it less exotic and arguably something the Church has addressed. And perhaps found lacking?
March 18, 2019
Three thoughts.
I question whether unserious early adopters are a problem or not. It seems that they are part of the process. The salons of Europe were full of gauche duffers espousing “limousine leftism” – or perhaps “gilded-carriage communism,” if you prefer – before those ideas percolated into the horrors of the 20th Century. I don’t see why the social psychology would be different for those in our camp.
While I find Mr. Dreher’s Evangelical-tinged consumerist outlook on culture and religion less than ideal, I can’t say that I am totally opposed to “options” if they are viewed as callings. A friend of mine who is an Opus Dei Co-Operator (a proper title) expressed concern at the Benedict Option because it dis-engaged from the culture, which is contrary to Opus Dei’s principles. In reply on-the-spot I said that I was a “pan-Optionist” insofar as I don’t think that everyone has the same calling. If some are looking to convert the heathen culture, and others are looking to build safe areas, as befits their temperaments and Divine Providence, well then, so be it.
Thank you for this excellent open question on Symphonia. I am now reading Dr. DeVille’s new work, “Everything Hidden Shall Be Revealed,” and the chapter on the corrosive effect of the trappings of papal monarchy on obsequious power worship in the Latin Church are fascinating. And there’s nothing I like more than medieval trappings, so it’s really challenging my world view.
August 11, 2020
гидра tor – гидра через тор браузер, гидра tor
August 11, 2020
azino777 ru официальный
azino777 официальный сайт зеркало на сегодня
August 11, 2020
vavada казино официальный мобильная версия
vavada казино скачать
August 11, 2020
супер слот онлайн казино
superslots casino com
August 11, 2020
пин ап казино вход
pin up casino промокод бездепозитный бонус
August 11, 2020
казино сол официальный сайт вход личный кабинет
сол казино приложение
August 11, 2020
заработок казино фараон
отзывы об интернет казино фараон россия
August 11, 2020
play fortuna casino официальный сайт зеркало
плей фортуна онлайн официальный сайт
August 11, 2020
слот в казино онлайн
слот в казино россия
August 11, 2020
покердом отзывы игроков
сайт покердом
August 11, 2020
вулкан слотс игровые автоматы
вулкан слотс скачать
August 11, 2020
Make $1000 from $1 in a few minutes. Launch the financial robot now.
Link – – https://tinyurl.com/y7t5j7yc
August 11, 2020
para que sirve la levitra de 20 mg buy generic levitra online was kostet levitra in spanien
August 11, 2020
Learn how to make hundreds of backs each day.
Link – https://tinyurl.com/y7t5j7yc
August 11, 2020
Invest $1 today to make $1000 tomorrow.
Link – https://tinyurl.com/y7t5j7yc
August 11, 2020
Try out the automatic robot to keep earning all day long.
Link – https://tinyurl.com/y7t5j7yc
August 11, 2020
http://prorezak.ru
August 11, 2020
человечный веб сайт
Пикантные секс рассказы про еблю
August 11, 2020
perdere peso in una settimana
August 12, 2020
Guys just made a site for me, look at the link:
https://www.google.com/url?sa=t&url=http%3A%2F%2Fmpxxi.ru/stolovye-nabory-iz-serebra/ Tell me your prescriptions. THX!
August 12, 2020
Make dollars just sitting home.
Link – https://tinyurl.com/y7t5j7yc
August 12, 2020
Sorry, I’m a bit MOOdy today cute cow pun Infant Creeper
Bedtime Originals Mod Monkey Diaper Stacker
August 12, 2020
казино икс casino x официальный
игровое казино х
August 12, 2020
Guys just made a website for me, look at the link:
http://bestideya.mystrikingly.com/ Tell me your guidances. Thanks!
August 12, 2020
Your computer can bring you additional income if you use this Robot.
Link – https://tinyurl.com/y7t5j7yc
August 12, 2020
web link empire market onion
August 12, 2020
This robot can bring you money 24/7.
Link – – https://tinyurl.com/y7t5j7yc
August 12, 2020
Make your laptop a financial instrument with this program.
Link – https://plbtc.page.link/zXbp
August 12, 2020
казино admiral x бонус
сайт адмирал икс
August 12, 2020
cialis generic cialis cheap cialis canadian pharmacy
August 12, 2020
find out here now empire market link
August 12, 2020
наркологический центр лечение наркомании – снятие наркотической ломки, принудительное лечение наркозависимых
August 12, 2020
look these up гидра зеркало
August 12, 2020
vulcan slots зеркало
vulkanslots net
August 12, 2020
click this site empire market links
August 12, 2020
репетитор математика – репетиторы по математике спб, русский егэ репетитор
August 12, 2020
Препараты качественные,купили на сайте anticancer24.ru
Доставили из Москвы за 3 дня
софосбувир +и даклатасвир 2019
August 12, 2020
промокод яндекс директ 3000 – купоны для яндекс директа, яндекс директ промокод купить
August 12, 2020
Just one click can turn you dollar into $1000.
Link – https://tinyurl.com/y7t5j7yc
August 12, 2020
Make thousands every week working online here.
Link – https://tinyurl.com/y7t5j7yc
August 12, 2020
Money, money! Make more money with financial robot!
Link – https://tinyurl.com/y7t5j7yc
August 12, 2020
No worries if you are fired. Work online.
Link – https://tinyurl.com/y7t5j7yc
August 12, 2020
#blackandwhitephoto
August 12, 2020
Самонесущий изолированный провод, другими словами СИП заказываю в проверенном интернет-магазине electrotorg.ru . Иногда езжу в их розничный магазин в Митино
August 12, 2020
I was just seeking this info for a while.
After 6 hours of continuous Googleing, finally I got it in your site.
I wonder what is the lack of Google strategy that don’t rank this type of informative websites in top of the list.
Generally the top websites are full of garbage.
My web-site … answers (https://www.gtainside.com/user/ommateum)
August 12, 2020
shy hairy tiny tit teen fuck
hot girl with hairy pussy masterbating
hairy nude girl image
pubic hair vagina pics
August 12, 2020
best price viagra viagra prescriptions over internet
August 12, 2020
Additional income is now available for anyone all around the world.
Link – – https://tinyurl.com/y7t5j7yc
August 17, 2020
YIWULA Cute Bath Toy Animal Rain Wa Terfall Bathtub Toy Children Gift
Baby Girls Royal Blue Rose Lace Overlay Beaded Waist Occasion Dress 3-24M
August 21, 2020
пин ап казино официальный сайт регистрация
pin up лицензионная казино
August 23, 2020
slot v com
slot v casino официальный сайт москва
August 23, 2020
вулкан слотс адрес
вулкан игровые автоматы слотс
August 27, 2020
come perdere la pancia
September 7, 2020
Препараты качественные,купили на сайте anticancer24.ru
Доставили из Москвы за 3 дня
софосбувир +и даклатасвир инструкция +по применению цена